Online Newspaper by and for Students of
St. Ignatius College Preparatory, San Francisco
  • Rethinking Africa: The staff of the African Advocacy Network includes Joe Sciarrillo, pictured here with Jean Elias Xavier, Director Aboudou Traore, Charles Jackson and Clementine Ntshaykolo outside their office in the Dolores Street Community Services building. They help a growing number of African immigrants to the Bay Area who may number as many as 50,000.
  • Retiring Pillars: SI’s faculty surprised Fr. Sauer in May with applause and flowers after the announcement of his reassignment.
  • The SI boys’ lacrosse team enjoyed what may have been best year since its founding nearly a quarter century ago. The lacrosse press ranked the team among the top 15 in the nation as SI turned in another undefeated season in league play – its fourth undefeated season since it joined the WCAL in 2010.
  • Richard Driscoll ’06, a performance engineer for Oracle Team USA that will defend the America’s Cup in September, is among the few locals hunkering down in Pier 80 off Marin Street, where they work 65-hour weeks to make sure that Ellison’s boat sails twice as fast as the wind and maneuvers with precision and power as it takes on challengers from around the world.
  • Retiring Pillars: Since the 1970s, Mary McCarty made sure Latin was a living language for students in her classes.
  • Rethinking Africa: Ira Shaughnessy ’00 spent two years in Ghana from 2007 to 2009 working with the Bormase helping with the cultivation of the Moringa tree, whose leaves are rich in vitamins.

Op Ed


SI Grad Weighs in on New SAT

Brenna Smith '15
Managing Editor

The SAT has always been a source of contention for high school students. Recently, David Coleman, College Board of CEO announced a remodeling of the 2016 SAT. The new test will be based more in classroom learning: no more obscure vocabulary words, required essays, or inconsequential math techniques.

The redesign raises questions: Why do the SATs exist? Does the SAT do more harm than good? Will the new SAT bridge the gap between rich and poor? SI graduate Mr. Randolf Arguelles, director of San Francisco’s Elite Academy and author of “The New SAT Will Widen the Education Gap” in the Wall Street Journal, addresses the injustice of the test.

BS: Mr. Arguelles, can you explain how the education gap between the rich and the poor will widen with the new SAT?

RA: The current SAT is puzzle-solving model, not a measure of learning, so it gives a smart kid from a “crappy school” a chance of getting into a better college. The test measures abstract reasoning, not the quality of teaching. The new version will penalize a smart kid from a weak school be- cause poor teaching will impact his or her results. Bad education will finally get in the way.

BS: SI students are privileged and can afford test prep classes. Should we feel guilty?

RA: No, no. Your parents just want the best for their kids. Parents and students should not feel guilty for test preparation. True, the higher the income, the better the SAT score. That needs to be addressed. That was my concern in my op-ed piece in the Wall Street Journal: this income gap will be exacerbated by the new SAT.

BS: Why even have the SAT, or standardized tests, in general?

RA: In a perfect world we wouldn’t need the SAT. Students would be evaluated in a more nuanced way. But it isn’t a perfect world. I also read for UC Berkeley. If Berkeley were to implement an essay entrance exam as some private col- leges with several thousand fewer applications, it would extend the reading season to four or six months, not the current two months. This would cost more money and would increase application fees. The SAT is a helpful metric for evaluating college students. It’s not ideal, but is a necessary data point.

BS: Does the SAT do more harm than good? RA: In a professional career, there will be some task that may seem completely pointless, yet difficult to achieve. But you will still have to do it to get to the next step in your career. The SAT is perhaps the first pointless, difficult task one has to overcome. We should all be so lucky that everything we do is fascinating or has a clear identifiable purpose, but that just doesn’t happen. The SAT is life preparation. Since the test is one large puzzle-solving exercise, test prep teaches people how to do the SAT puzzles. That being said, the SAT is not a measure of your intelligence or worthiness to go to a certain college. BS: Any last minute advice for students gearing up to take the SAT?

RA: College admissions is not about justice. Perfectly qualified students are turned down by Harvard and Princeton and the UCs. Unqualified students get in because they are athletes, legacies, and contribute other talents. The system is not meant to be just but to build the best freshman class they can.

There has been a significant shift in college ad- missions where you can be a specialist in one area. Previously colleges wanted the well-rounded student (grades, sports, orchestra, community service, etc.). Now colleges do not recruit well-rounded individuals: they recruit a well-rounded freshman class by bringing in people with specialties.

The best favor you could do for yourself is be- come an avid reader. Read veraciously with a dictionary. Studies show that successful college students read all the time. More than income, reading correlates with both the math and read- ing scores. Another thing to keep in mind: You should nourish the mind, soul, and body. It’s a life-long task.

Posted by on Sunday April, 13, 2014


Choose groups to clone to:

St. Ignatius College Preparatory
Privacy Policy 

2001 37th Avenue
San Francisco, CA  94116
(415) 731-7500
Contact Us

email page print page small type large type
powered by finalsite