Online Newspaper by and for Students of
St. Ignatius College Preparatory, San Francisco
  • Rethinking Africa: The staff of the African Advocacy Network includes Joe Sciarrillo, pictured here with Jean Elias Xavier, Director Aboudou Traore, Charles Jackson and Clementine Ntshaykolo outside their office in the Dolores Street Community Services building. They help a growing number of African immigrants to the Bay Area who may number as many as 50,000.
  • Retiring Pillars: SI’s faculty surprised Fr. Sauer in May with applause and flowers after the announcement of his reassignment.
  • The SI boys’ lacrosse team enjoyed what may have been best year since its founding nearly a quarter century ago. The lacrosse press ranked the team among the top 15 in the nation as SI turned in another undefeated season in league play – its fourth undefeated season since it joined the WCAL in 2010.
  • Richard Driscoll ’06, a performance engineer for Oracle Team USA that will defend the America’s Cup in September, is among the few locals hunkering down in Pier 80 off Marin Street, where they work 65-hour weeks to make sure that Ellison’s boat sails twice as fast as the wind and maneuvers with precision and power as it takes on challengers from around the world.
  • Retiring Pillars: Since the 1970s, Mary McCarty made sure Latin was a living language for students in her classes.
  • Rethinking Africa: Ira Shaughnessy ’00 spent two years in Ghana from 2007 to 2009 working with the Bormase helping with the cultivation of the Moringa tree, whose leaves are rich in vitamins.

Op Ed


How Much P. E. Do Athletes Need?

Nathan Reutiman ’15
Contributing Editor


Few SI students completely understand our P.E. Waiver. After a great deal of digging and research, I am honestly perplexed at what I have learned.  A standard answer was: “Can you tell me what it is before I answer?” What started as a lack of knowledge quickly turned to confusion and frustration. Ignorance was bliss.


Let me explain: SI requires two semesters of PE: one unisex P.E. class in the freshman year, and one elective, such as fitness, weightlifting, or dance, to be taken in the sophomore or senior year. The second semester can only be waived if a student plays three seasons in two sports past the freshman level, one of which must be at the varsity level.


 Even though most of us would agree that Fitness and Health Education component is essential, the second semester seems superfluous for our athletes. Our rival schools are not so rigid. For example Bellarmine does not have a P.E. requirement, and Sacred Heart gives P.E. credit for school or outside club sports. Other high schools offer a waiver to student athletes after fitness tests to make their team, assuming they are getting exercise just by nature of their participation.


 On the other hand, our requirement for “two different sports” excludes single-sport athletes. How many student athletes does such a simple requirement affect?


 There are 1,469 students at SI. According to the About SI Athletics page, “70% of students will participate in athletics” and “400 will play two sports.” With some simple arithmetic, SI has 630 single sport athletes, and these 630 SI student athletes will not be exempted from a P.E. elective.


 In many cases, these are athletes who have devoted themselves to and excelled at a sport for all four years; most play their sport year round in offseason training or training with outside clubs. For example, how could one argue that a crew team member is unfit?


 Consider a single sport athlete who, as a varsity player, is required to lift before school three times a week. This athlete will face early mornings and grueling physical activity, but will never receive P.E. credit. Ironically, a student enrolled in a weight lifting class does the same exact lifting routine and receives P.E. credit.


 But this isn’t the only issue. With only a limited number of electives available in a student’s schedule, the second semester of the P.E. requirement inhibits our opportunity to expand into different areas of interest. As Joseph Ladd ’15, a three year varsity golfer, expressed, “I’m a little upset that I can’t take architecture. It (P.E.) takes up a year of a class that I could really benefit from, especially when figuring out interests for future college courses.” Joe sums up the issue 630 athletes have to struggle with.


 There is one more element to consider. SI’s curriculum has dramatically changed in the last year in any number of positive ways. Last year, SI introduced the mandatory Wellness seminar: a yearlong sophomore course that covers a vast range of health education topics, similar to the health education requirements at many others schools such as Lick-Wilmerding. With the addition of the Wellness course, is it possible that SI’s second semester of the P.E. requirement--intended to instill life fitness and health awareness--has become redundant?


 SI should reconsider the requirements to obtain a P.E. waiver. Seniors should be able to choose more preferable, beneficial electives. A re-evaluation of thve P.E. requirement would prove a liberating step in SI’s continued path towards achieving and maintaining academic excellence.

Posted by on Friday February, 28, 2014


Choose groups to clone to:

St. Ignatius College Preparatory
Privacy Policy 

2001 37th Avenue
San Francisco, CA  94116
(415) 731-7500
Contact Us

email page print page small type large type
powered by finalsite